Matches in DBpedia 2015-10 for { <http://dbpedia.org/resource/Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others> ?p ?o }
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others abstract "Novartis v. Union of India & Others is a landmark decision by a two-judge bench of the Indian Supreme Court on the issue of whether Novartis could patent Gleevec in India, and was the culmination of a seven-year-long litigation fought by Novartis. The Supreme Court upheld the Indian patent office's rejection of the patent application.The patent application at the center of the case was filed by Novartis in India in 1998, after India had agreed to enter the World Trade Organization and to abide by worldwide intellectual property standards under the TRIPS agreement. As part of this agreement, India made changes to its patent law; the biggest of which was that prior to these changes, patents on products were not allowed, while afterwards they were, albeit with restrictions. These changes came into effect in 2005, so Novartis' patent application waited in a "mailbox" with others until then, under procedures that India instituted to manage the transition. India also passed certain amendments to its patent law in 2005, just before the laws came into effect, which played a key role in the rejection of the patent application.The patent application claimed the final form of Gleevec (the beta crystalline form of imatinib mesylate). In 1993, during the time India did not allow patents on products, Novartis had patented imatinib, with salts vaguely specified, in many countries but could not patent it in India. The key differences between the two patent applications, were that the 1998 patent application specified the counterion (Gleevec is a specific salt - imatinib mesylate) while the 1993 patent application did not claim any specific salts nor did it mention mesylate, and the 1998 patent application specified the solid form of Gleevec - the way the individual molecules are packed together into a solid when the drug itself is manufactured (this is separate from processes by which the drug itself is formulated into pills or capsules) - while the 1993 patent application did not. The solid form of imatinib mesylate in Gleevec is beta crystalline.As provided under the TRIPS agreement, Novartis applied for Exclusive Marketing Rights (EMR) for Gleevec from the Indian Patent Office and the EMR were granted in November 2003. Novartis made use of the EMR to obtain orders against some generic manufacturers who had already launched Gleevec in India. Novartis set the price of Gleevec at USD 2666 per patient per month; generic companies were selling their versions at USD 177 to 266 per patient per month. Novartis also initiated a program to assist patients who could not afford its version of the drug, concurrent with its product launch.When examination of Novartis' patent application began in 2005, it came under immediate attack from oppositions initiated by generic companies that were already selling Gleevec in India and by advocacy groups. The application was rejected by the patent office and by an appeal board. The key basis for the rejection was the part of Indian patent law that was created by amendment in 2005, describing the patentability of new uses for known drugs and modifications of known drugs. That section, Paragraph 3d, specified that such inventions are patentable only if "they differ significantly in properties with regard to efficacy." At one point, Novartis went to court to try to invalidate Paragraph 3d; it argued that the provision was unconstitutionally vague and that it violated TRIPS. Novartis lost that case and did not appeal. Novartis did appeal the rejection by the patent office to India's Supreme Court, which took the case.The Supreme Court case hinged on the interpretation of Paragraph 3d. The Supreme Court decided that the substance that Novartis sought to patent was indeed a modification of a known drug (the raw form of imatinib, which was publicly disclosed in the 1993 patent application and in scientific articles), that Novartis did not present evidence of a difference in therapeutic efficacy between the final form of Gleevec and the raw form of imatinib, and that therefore the patent application was properly rejected by the patent office and lower courts.Although the court ruled narrowly, and took care to note that the subject application was filed during a time of transition in Indian patent law, the decision generated widespread global news coverage and reignited debates on balancing public good with monopolistic pricing and innovation with affordability. Had Novartis won and gotten its patent issued, it could not have prevented generics companies in India from continuing to sell generic Gleevec, but it could have obligated them to pay a reasonable royalty under a grandfather clause included in India's patent law.".
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageExternalLink qrydispfree.aspx?filename=11121.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageExternalLink imgs1.aspx?filename=40212.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageExternalLink IPAB-Order-Dated-26-Jun-2009-in-Novartis-v-Union-of-India.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageExternalLink statute-combined%20patents%20act%202005.pdf.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageID "39015608".
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageLength "40951".
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageOutDegree "65".
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageRevisionID "677789401".
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Active_ingredient.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Amorphous.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Amorphous_solid.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Approved_Drug_Products_with_Therapeutic_Equivalence_Evaluations.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Bioavailability.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Cancer_Research_(journal).
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Category:2013_in_India.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Category:2013_in_case_law.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Category:Indian_intellectual_property_law.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Category:Indian_patent_case_law.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Category:Novartis.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Category:Pharmaceutical_industry_of_India.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Category:Supreme_Court_of_India_cases.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Chemical_stability.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Commonwealth.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Constitution_of_India.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Counterion.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink De_novo_review.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Doha_Declaration.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink European_Patent_Office.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Evergreening.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Food_and_Drug_Administration.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Free_base.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Gopal_Subramaniam.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Grandfather_clause.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Hygroscopicity.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Hygroscopy.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Imatinib.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Indian_Constitution.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Indian_Patent_Office.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Indian_Supreme_Court.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Intellectual_property.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink International_Nonproprietary_Name.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Invention.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Landmark_decision.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink List_of_High_Courts_of_India.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Lists_of_landmark_court_decisions.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Madras_High_Court.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Mesylate.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Methanesulfonic_acid.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Method_(patent).
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Médecins_Sans_Frontières.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Nature_(journal).
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Novartis.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Opposition_proceeding.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Paras_Kuhad.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Pharmaceutical_formulation.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Pharmaceutical_industry_in_India.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Polymorphism_(materials_science).
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Prior_art.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Process_patent.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Salt_(chemistry).
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Solicitor_General_of_India.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Standard_of_review.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Supreme_Court_of_India.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink T._R._Andhyarujina.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink TRIPS.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink TRIPS_Agreement.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink T_R_Andhyarujina.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Thermodynamic_stability.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink Time_(magazine).
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink USPTO.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink United_States_Patent_and_Trademark_Office.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink World_Health_Organisation.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink World_Health_Organization.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink World_Trade_Organisation.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink World_Trade_Organization.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLink File:Imatinib.svg.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLinkText "Novartis case".
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLinkText "Novartis v. Union of India & Others".
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLinkText "legal challenge against India's patent law".
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageWikiLinkText "the Indian Supreme Court issued a decision".
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others argueyear "2012".
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others citation imgs1.aspx?filename=40212.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others decidedate "--04-01".
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others decideyear "2013".
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others fullname "Novartis AG v. Union of India and Ors.; Natco Pharma Ltd. v. UoI & Ors.; M/S Cancer Patients Aid Association v. UoI & Ors.".
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others hasPhotoCollection Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others holding "Upheld the rejection of the patent application filed by Novartis AG for Glivec in 1998 before the Indian Patent Office.".
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others joinmajority "Ms. Justice Ranjana Prakash Desai".
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others lawsapplied "Sections 2, 2 and 3 of Indian Patent Act, 1970 (as amended in 2005)".
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others litigants "Novartis AG v. Union of India".
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others majority "Mr. Justice Aftab Alam".
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others prior "--01-25".
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageUsesTemplate Template:Italic_title.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageUsesTemplate Template:Reflist.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageUsesTemplate Template:Rp.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageUsesTemplate Template:SCICase.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others wikiPageUsesTemplate Template:See_also.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others subject Category:2013_in_India.
- Novartis_v._Union_of_India_&_Others subject Category:2013_in_case_law.