Matches in DBpedia 2016-04 for { <http://dbpedia.org/resource/Sternberg_peer_review_controversy> ?p ?o }
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy abstract "The Sternberg peer review controversy concerns the conflict arising from the publication of an article supporting the controversial concept of intelligent design in a scientific journal, and the subsequent questions of whether proper editorial procedures had been followed and whether it was properly peer reviewed.One of the primary criticisms of the intelligent design movement is that there are no research papers supporting their positions in peer reviewed scientific journals. On 4 August 2004, an article by Stephen C. Meyer (Director of Discovery Institute's Center for Science and Culture) titled \"The origin of biological information and the higher taxonomic categories\", appeared in the peer-reviewed journal, Proceedings of the Biological Society of Washington. Meyer's article was a literature review article, and contained no new primary scholarship itself on the topic of intelligent design. The following month, the publisher of the journal, the Council of the Biological Society of Washington, released a statement repudiating the article and stating that their former editor Richard M. Sternberg had, in an unusual manner, handled the entire review process without consultation or review from an associate editor. The position of editor was unpaid and voluntary, and Sternberg had put in his resignation from it six months earlier. Sternberg disputes the Council's statement and asserts that the paper was appropriately peer reviewed by three biologists who \"concluded that [the paper] warranted publication\".The same statement from the Council vowed that proper review procedures would be followed in the future and endorsed a resolution published by the American Association for the Advancement of Science, which states that there is no credible scientific evidence supporting intelligent design. On September 18, the Discovery Institute issued a statement praising the publication of Meyer's paper in a peer-reviewed journal and chastising the National Center for Science Education for stating that the paper should not have been published. The Biological Society of Washington's president, Roy McDiarmid called Sternberg's decision to publish Meyer's article \"a really bad judgment call on the editor's part\" and said it was doubtful whether the three scientists who peer reviewed the article and recommended it for publication were evolutionary biologists.".
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageExternalLink index.php?command=view&id=2177&program=CSC&callingPage=discoMainPage.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageExternalLink c14871.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageExternalLink www.richardsternberg.com.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageID "3140813".
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageLength "35727".
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageOutDegree "94".
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageRevisionID "701965224".
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink A_Scientific_Dissent_From_Darwinism.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Alan_Gishlick.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink American_Association_for_the_Advancement_of_Science.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Baraminology.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Barbara_Bradley_Hagerty.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Ben_Stein.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Binghamton_University.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Biologic_Institute.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Biological_Society_of_Washington.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Bryan_College.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Cambrian_explosion.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Category:Discovery_Institute_campaigns.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Category:Intelligent_design_controversies.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Category:Peer_review.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Category:Smithsonian_Institution.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Catholic_Church.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Center_for_Science_and_Culture.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Chris_Mooney_(journalist).
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Chris_de_Freitas.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Christian_right.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Clarence_Darrow.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Climate_change_denial.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Controversy.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Crab.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Creation_science.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink David_Klinghoffer.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Discovery_Institute.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Discovery_Institute_intelligent_design_campaigns.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Expelled:_No_Intelligence_Allowed.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Florida_International_University.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink George_W._Bush.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Intelligent_design.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Intelligent_design_movement.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink International_Society_for_Complexity,_Information,_and_Design.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink James_McVay.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Literature_review.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Mark_Souder.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Michael_Shermer.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Molecular_evolution.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink NPR.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink National_Center_for_Biotechnology_Information.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink National_Center_for_Science_Education.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink National_Institutes_of_Health.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink National_Museum_of_Natural_History.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Nick_Matzke.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Paleontology.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Peer_review.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Phillip_E._Johnson.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Phylogenetics.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Republican_Party_(United_States).
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Rick_Santorum.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Sallie_Baliunas.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Santorum_Amendment.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Scientific_American.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Scientific_journal.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Scopes_Trial.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Skeptic_(U.S._magazine).
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Smithsonian_Institution.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Species.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Stephen_C._Meyer.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Structuralism_(biology).
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Systematics.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Systems_science.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Taxonomy_(biology).
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink The_Wall_Street_Journal.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink United_States_House_Committee_on_Oversight_and_Government_Reform.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink United_States_House_of_Representatives.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink United_States_Office_of_Special_Counsel.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink University_of_South_Carolina.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Wesley_R._Elsberry.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink William_Jennings_Bryan.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Willie_Soon.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Young_Earth_creationism.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLinkText "Richard Sternberg".
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLinkText "Sternberg peer review controversy".
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLinkText "a peer-review controversy".
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLinkText "peer review controversy".
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageWikiLinkText "quickly withdrawn by the publisher".
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageUsesTemplate Template:Quotation.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy wikiPageUsesTemplate Template:Reflist.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy subject Category:Discovery_Institute_campaigns.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy subject Category:Intelligent_design_controversies.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy subject Category:Peer_review.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy subject Category:Smithsonian_Institution.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy type Controversy.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy type Organization.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy type Organization.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy comment "The Sternberg peer review controversy concerns the conflict arising from the publication of an article supporting the controversial concept of intelligent design in a scientific journal, and the subsequent questions of whether proper editorial procedures had been followed and whether it was properly peer reviewed.One of the primary criticisms of the intelligent design movement is that there are no research papers supporting their positions in peer reviewed scientific journals.".
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy label "Sternberg peer review controversy".
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy sameAs Q7611551.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy sameAs m.08v021.
- Sternberg_peer_review_controversy sameAs Q7611551.