Matches in DBpedia 2016-04 for { <http://dbpedia.org/resource/Hopi_time_controversy> ?p ?o }
- Hopi_time_controversy abstract "The Hopi time controversy is the academic debate about how the Hopi language grammaticalizes the concept of time, and about whether the differences between the ways the English and Hopi languages describe time are an example of linguistic relativity or not. In popular discourse the debate is often framed as a question about whether the Hopi \"have a concept of time\", despite it now being well established that they do.The debate originated in the 1940s when American linguist Benjamin Lee Whorf argued that the Hopi conceptualized time differently from the Standard Average European speaker, and that this difference correlated with grammatical differences between the languages. Whorf argued that Hopi has \"no words, grammatical forms, construction or expressions that refer directly to what we call 'time'\", and concluded that the Hopi had \"no general notion or intuition of time as a smooth flowing continuum in which everything in the universe proceeds at equal rate, out of a future, through the present, into a past\". Whorf used the Hopi concept of time as a primary example of his concept of linguistic relativity, which posits that the way in which individual languages encode information about the world, influences and correlates with the cultural world view of the speakers. Whorf's relativist views fell out of favor in linguistics and anthropology in the 1960s, but Whorf's statement lived on in the popular literature often in the form of an urban myth that \"The Hopi have no concept of time\". In 1983 linguist Ekkehart Malotki published a 600-page study of the grammar of time in the Hopi language, concluding that he had finally refuted Whorf's claims about the language. Malotki's treatise gave hundreds of examples of Hopi words and grammatical forms referring to temporal relations. Malotki's central claim was that the Hopi do indeed conceptualize time as structured in terms of an ego-centered spatial progression from past, through present into the future. He also demonstrated that the Hopi language grammaticalizes tense using a distinction between future and non-future tenses, as opposed to the English tense system, which is usually analyzed as being based on a past/non-past distinction. Many took Malotki's work as the final nail in the coffin of the linguistic relativity hypothesis. Linguist and specialist in the linguistic typology of tense Bernard Comrie concluded that \"Malotki's presentation and argumentation are devastating\". Psychologist Steven Pinker, a well-known critic of Whorf and the concept of linguistic relativity, accepted Malotki's claims as having demonstrated Whorf's complete ineptitude as a linguist.Subsequently the study of linguistic relativity was revived using new approaches in the 1990s, and Malotki's study came under criticism from relativist linguists and anthropologists, who did not consider that the study invalidated Whorf's claims. The main issue of contention is the interpretation of Whorf's original claims about Hopi, and what exactly it was that he was claiming made Hopi different from what Whorf called \"Standard Average European\" languages. Some consider that the Hopi language may be best described as a tenseless language, and that the distinction between non-future and future posited by Malotki may be better understood as a distinction between realis and irrealis moods. Regardless of exactly how the Hopi concept of time is best analyzed, most specialists agree with Malotki that all humans conceptualize time by an analogy with space, although some recent studies have also questioned this.".
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageExternalLink 16325.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageID "37125418".
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageLength "49115".
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageOutDegree "95".
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageRevisionID "708001296".
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Albert_Einstein.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Alfred_Tozzer.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Anna_Wierzbicka.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Annus_Mirabilis_papers.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Anthropology.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Aristotle.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Arizona.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Benjamin_Lee_Whorf.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Bernard_Comrie.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Category:Anthropological_linguistics.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Category:Arguments_in_philosophy_of_mind.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Category:Ethnolinguistics.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Category:Hopi.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Category:Linguistic_controversies.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Category:Philosophy_of_language.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Category:Philosophy_of_time.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Category:Psycholinguistics.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Category:Relativism.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Category:Time_in_linguistics.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Cliff_Goddard.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Cognitive_linguistics.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Conditional_mood.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Counterfactual_thinking.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink David_Dinwoodie.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Desiderative_mood.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Edward_Sapir.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Ekkehart_Malotki.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Epistemology.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Four-dimensional_space.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Grammatical_aspect.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Grammatical_mood.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Grammatical_tense.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Harry_Hoijer.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Hermann_Minkowski.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Hopi.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Hopi_Dictionary:_Hopìikwa_Lavàytutuveni.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Hopi_Reservation.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Hopi_language.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Hortative.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Hotevilla-Bacavi,_Arizona.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Immanuel_Kant.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Imperative_mood.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Indigenous_languages_of_the_Americas.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Indo-European_languages.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Isaac_Newton.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Jeanette_Winterson.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink John_A._Lucy.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink John_Bissell_Carroll.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink John_Greenway_(folklorist).
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink John_Locke.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink John_McWhorter.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Language_(journal).
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Leo_Weisgerber.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Linguistic_Society_of_America.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Linguistic_relativity.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Linguistic_typology.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Linguistics.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Manhattan.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Max_Black.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Münster.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Nahuatl.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Natural_semantic_metalanguage.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink New_Age.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Noun.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Piki.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Psycholinguistics.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Relative_clause.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Second_Mesa,_Arizona.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Semantics.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Sexing_the_Cherry.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Standard_Average_European.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Steven_Pinker.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Stuart_Chase.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Tenseless_language.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink The_Language_Instinct.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink University_of_Arizona_Press.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink University_of_Münster.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Urban_legend.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Uto-Aztecan_languages.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Wilhelm_von_Humboldt.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink World_view.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLink Yale_University.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLinkText "Hopi have no concept of time".
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLinkText "Hopi time controversy".
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLinkText "a point of controversy".
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageWikiLinkText "time as a conceptual category among the Hopi".
- Hopi_time_controversy colwidth "30".
- Hopi_time_controversy indent "yes".
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageUsesTemplate Template:Blockquote.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageUsesTemplate Template:Cite_book.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageUsesTemplate Template:Cite_journal.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageUsesTemplate Template:Cite_news.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageUsesTemplate Template:Harvcoltxt.
- Hopi_time_controversy wikiPageUsesTemplate Template:Quote.